"Tell me Sarah, what do you think of my labyrinth?" - Labyrinth (1986) about | advertise | classifieds | legal | myspace | staff | submit for review | support
 
FREE Weekly Newsletter



 
 
     
 
   
 
     
WHAT WE DO IS SECRET
by Eric Campos
2007, Un-rated, 90 minutes
In the works for over ten years, it was inevitable that word would hit the web about the Germs/Darby Crash movie, and it did…and that word wasn’t always the most encouraging. Being that The Germs are regarded as the most important band to come out of the late seventies Los Angeles punk rock scene, old school punkers crossed their arms defiantly and prepared to poo-poo anything they heard about the movie. Finally they were supplied the ammo they had been dreaming about when it was announced that Shane West would be portraying Darby Crash in the biopic. Everyone balked at an actor best known for his work on “E.R.” playing their punk rock God. You gotta understand, punk rockers can be very stubborn people. And thus began the major shit-talking. Years passed and due to several production delays it looked like the Germs movie would never come to be, but first time feature filmmaker Rodger Grossman believed in this story and he stuck to his guns in order to make sure it was told. After ten years of speculation and adversity, the Germs movie has arrived and “What We Do Is Secret” should be kept as anything but a secret.

Within the first few opening moments of “What We Do is Secret,” Shane West, stalking a tiny club stage as Darby Crash, whines, “Someone get me a beeeeeer,” and with that, all doubt of West’s ability to play this role is gone. There he is. Darby Crash is resurrected in all of his furious glory. West portrays the punk rocker during his legendary “five-year plan,” which would see he and buddy George Ruthenberg (who would later become Pat Smear) forming a band made up of members who knew nothing about playing musical instruments. They would become The Germs and they would learn to play as they went, quickly carving their notoriety into the Los Angeles punk rock scene in the late seventies. The film chronicles the band’s rise to fame, which would ultimately find them banned from every rock club in town due to their penchant for inciting riots at their own shows. “What We Do Is Secret” is loaded with plenty of violent live performances, featuring Shane West pulling off a flawless Darby Crash impersonation, smashing bottles over his head, cutting himself with the jagged shards and spraying his lyrics and blood all over the audience. If you’ve never seen The Germs play live, this is the next best thing and you’re in for a helluva ride. But then a good deal of the film also focuses on the demise of The Germs and Darby’s wind down of his five-year plan which leads him to commit suicide by self-administering an overdose of heroin on December 7, 1980, the day before John Lennon was killed. It’s not all kicking and screaming punk rock fury – there’s a surprisingly touching human drama here, as well.

I’ve already mentioned Shane West turning in a tits perfect performance as Darby Crash,. but the rest of the cast provides plenty of movie candy to chew on, as well – the rest of The Germs for example with Rick Gonzalez (“Roll Bounce”) as Pat Smear, Bijou Phillips (“Hostel: Part II”) as Lorna Doom and Noah Segan (“Brick”) as the one only Don Bolles. The rest of the scene is filled out with Lauren German (“Hostel: Part II”) as Belina Carlisle, Sebastian Roche (“General Hospital”) as Kickboy Face – Slash magazine editor and frontman for Catholic Discipline, Ozzy Ben as Captain Sensible and Christopher Boyd as Dave Vanian of The Damned, Ray Park (Darth Maul) as Masque founder Brendan Mullen, J.P. Manoux (“Knocked Up”) as Rodney Bingenheimer and a surprise, but perfect, appearance from professional jackass Chris Pontius as one of punk rock’s most feared men - Black Randy of Black Randy and the Metro Squad. These actors and many more make “What We Do Is Secret” an absolute blast to watch and they do an undeniably perfect job of recreating this notorious scene.

Attention to detail is another thing that goes a long way in sucking the viewer back into this long gone era. For instance, during the recreation of a Screamers show you can hear someone in background hollreing that they want to hear “122 Hours of Fear,” not exactly the most well-known song on the planet, so when you notice stuff like that, you know that the filmmaker and his crew knew what they were doing and I don’t think a Germs fan could ask for more of this biopic.

It’s apparent that a lot of care, research and blood, sweat and tears went into this production. The road to completion must have been arduous. Good news is that all efforts have led to success. The Germs movie is finally here and it is a more than worthy tribute to one of punk rock’s largest heroes.

So, all you naysayers, swallow some pride and go see the fuckin’ movie already. You’ll still be punk rock afterwards. I promise.



 
gerrim
READER
 
I can not wait to see this movie! Noah Segan plays a lead role in our film, Still Green, and he came to our set right after filming WWDIS. I have been waiting to see this movie forever and now it is finally here. SWEEEETTT!!!!!  
Posted on July 11, 2008, 12:51 pm
Graham Rae
READER
 
The Germs are the most important band to come out of the late 70s punk scene...sez who, Compost? They're a nonentity. And as for all these self-important punk docs and biopix and whatnot...ENOUGH ALREADY. Punk WAS NOT that important a musical movement. Get over yourself, former damage case dix.  
Posted on August 8, 2008, 9:08 am
Midnight Crash
READER
 
Nice work Graham! Give it too those guys, I mean what the hell is punk anyways!? It's not like it was one of the most influential movements in rock history or anything, and it for sure hasn't influenced bands that you like or the open lyrics in music across the board... So yeah, what of punk anyways!  
Posted on August 16, 2008, 11:38 am
Johnny99
READER
 
One could argue that nothing that popular music has produced since the dawn of recorded music is all that important in the scheme of life and death, but to not recognise that punk was a bloody howl of despair against rock star boneheads and their 20 minute solos is simply ignorant. Sadly, like all youth culture rebellions, misguided or otherwise, punk was sucked in by the industry of pop culture, defanged and sold back to the next generation of kids like so much cellophaned supermarket meat. But for a moment or two...it was a very exciting time, people hated or were afraid of punk and it's followers and to fly that flag was to make a statement about conformity and boredom, and the music and shows was fucking exciting. Go back to your listening to Green Day CD dude...oh wait, where did that mega selling band cop all it's riffs from??  
Posted on August 28, 2008, 10:23 am
dhuber
READER
 
WWDIS was a great portrayal of the early punk scene as well as the Germs. I would recommend that any of you skeptical "punks" out there watch it for yourself!!  
Posted on September 2, 2008, 1:33 pm
vkimble
READER
 
dhube. way to pose. don't disrespect punk or this amazing movie with your tom foolery.  
Posted on September 4, 2008, 1:04 pm
Leave Comments:
UserName:
Password:
If you do not have a UserName or Password, register with Film Threat.
Comment:
Enter the text in the below image in the following space:
All HTML and other coding languages are stripped from the comments, so any added links or special text formating will not be active.
Read more reviews ...
  2009-11-19 - PROMETHEUS TRIUMPHANT: A FUGUE IN THE KEY OF FLESH  
  2009-11-19 - THE TWILIGHT SAGA: NEW MOON  
  2009-11-19 - TINTO BRASS' THE HOWL (L’URLO) (DVD)  
  2009-11-19 - BAD LIEUTENANT: PORT OF CALL NEW ORLEANS  
  2009-11-18 - POISON SWEETHEARTS  
  2009-11-17 - RIVER OF RENEWAL (DVD)  
  2009-11-17 - PLANET B-BOY (DVD)  
  2009-11-16 - 2012  
  2009-11-15 - INSIDE DARKNESS  
  2009-11-14 - GOOD EVENING FOLKS, WE’RE THE PINE BOX BOYS  
  2009-11-14 - ABBY  
  2009-11-13 - PIRATE RADIO  
  2009-11-13 - THE END OF POVERTY?  
  2009-11-12 - BONECRUSHER  
  2009-11-12 - NORTH BY NORTHWEST: 50TH ANNIVERSARY EDITION (DVD)  
  2009-11-11 - PAURA: LUCIO FULCI REMEMBERED VOL. 1 (DVD)  
  2009-11-11 - SUPER 8 GIRL GAMES (DVD)  
  2009-11-10 - UP: TWO-DISC DELUXE EDITION (DVD)  
  2009-11-10 - LOVE AND SAVAGERY  
  2009-11-08 - LUIS BUNUEL'S DEATH IN THE GARDEN (DVD)  
  2009-11-08 - PAROLES ET MUSIQUE (LOVE SONGS) (DVD)  
  2009-11-07 - THE MEN WHO STARE AT GOATS  
  2009-11-07 - CLONES GONE WILD  
  2009-11-06 - THE BOX  
  2009-11-06 - THE FOURTH KIND  
     

Headlines
 

Latest Blogs
TRUTH BEHIND "THE FOURTH KIND"? UNIVERSAL ASKS THAT YOU SEE FOR YOURSELF...
A FRIENDLY REMINDER -- FOLLOW FT ON TWITTER
"HOOTERS" WITH SCOOPERS
SOUND ON SIGHT: ANTICHRIST, FESTIVAL DU NOUVEAU CINEMA & A FEW OTHER THINGS
SOUND ON SIGHT: COPPOLA & THE COVE

NEW ON DVD!
UP: TWO-DISC DELUXE EDITION (DVD)
BALLAST
LUIS BUNUEL'S DEATH IN THE GARDEN (DVD)
FOOD, INC.
BATTLESTAR GALACTICA: THE PLAN (DVD)
UP
NORTH BY NORTHWEST: 50TH ANNIVERSARY EDITION (DVD)
STAR TREK

Film Threat Poll
Does 2012 deserve all the hype and coin it's getting?
1) Yes - it's bringing the world down!
2) It's a giant stink bomb.
3) Cusack and Harrelson should co-star in a gay romance.
In Theaters
BAD LIEUTENANT: PORT OF CALL NEW ORLEANS
THE TWILIGHT SAGA: NEW MOON
2012
PIRATE RADIO
THE MEN WHO STARE AT GOATS
THE FOURTH KIND
THE BOX
THIS IS IT
AN EDUCATION
SAW VI




Site Programming
Site Artwork
copyright © 1985-2009
Gore Group Publications
   
about | advertise | classifieds | legal | myspace | staff | submit for review | support