"I'm sorry I had to fight in the middle of your Black Panther party." - Forrest Gump (1994) about | advertise | classifieds | legal | myspace | staff | submit for review | support
 
FREE Weekly Newsletter



 
 
     
 
   
 
     
SPEED RACER
by Pete Vonder Haar
2008, Rated PG, 129 minutes, Warner Bros.
When the original “Speed Racer” cartoon entered American syndication in the 1970s, it marked the beginning of the Japanese animation movement (to paraphrase “Die Hard’s” Mr. Takagi: Pearl Harbor didn’t work, so they got us with Tenchi). It was also nearly unwatchable: a crudely drawn, incoherent mish-mash of recycled footage, sloppy overdubbing, and childish dialogue. That it enjoys the reputation it does is based almost solely on the fact that it was usually the first anime most people over the age of 30 remember seeing, even if few actually admit to watching it. Were we in any era other than the early 21st century, when even Irwin Allen movies are fodder for Hollywood’s regurgitation fetish, I’d have been surprised to hear that anyone was bothering to revisit it.

Enter the Wachowskis, who – either in reaction to the less than enthusiastic response that greeted the last two “Matrix” movies, or in an attempt to bury discussion of Larry’s personal life, whatever – decided that a big-screen “Speed Racer” flick was the perfect vehicle (he ha ho) for their directorial comeback.

Hearing the advance buzz on the movie, most of it negative, and given my own lack of affection for the source material, my expectations couldn’t have been lower. Which could be why I’m having such a difficult time dismissing the movie out of hand. It isn’t going to set the world on fire, but it’s perfectly acceptable for what it is.

The action at first weaves back and forth between a young Speed Racer daydreaming about driving a race car and the present-day adult version actually doing so. Through these flashbacks, we learn that Speed (Emile Hirsch) grew up idolizing his big brother Rex, who left the family for vague reasons and was later killed. In these first scenes, Speed is literally racing Rex’s ghost on the track where his deceased brother holds the course record.

After winning the race, Speed is approached by Mr. Royalton (Roger Allam), a super-duper industrialist who wants the young man for his racing team. He makes an attractive proposal, but after agonizing over the decision with mother “Mom” (Susan Sarandon), father “Pops” (John Goodman), and girlfriend “Trixie” (Christina Ricci, looking creepily like Sarandon), Speed decides to stay independent. Royalton vows revenge, essentially telling Speed he’ll never race in this town again. Shortly thereafter, Speed is approached by “Inspector Detector” and the mysterious Racer X (Matthew Fox), who offer him a chance to put the crooked Royalton behind bars.

Within five minutes, it’s apparent that the cinematic “Speed Racer” is nearly as much a cartoon as the original. Aside from close-ups and a few group cast shots in front of a massive green screen, everything else in the movie – from the vehicles to the sky itself – consists of garish computer animation and elaborately rendered backgrounds. Animation purists will decry the antiseptic feel of the endeavor while possibly questioning the use of live actors in the first place. And then they’ll complain about getting a headache.

But let’s not forget, the original “Speed Racer” was a cartoon for children, and the movie doesn’t exactly aim for a more cerebral demographic. Kids, you’ll cheer as our squeaky clean protagonists show how one person really can take a stand against the forces of greed and corruption. And have you ever wondered what it must be like to drive a car made out of Lite Brite through a Hot Wheels Turbo Tunnel? Now you know! There’s also enough swear words to warrant a PG rating (but not so many that your parents will leave in a huff), a chimp, and one solid kick in the nuts.

All that’s lacking is a free pint of chocolate milk with each ticket sold.

Had the Wachowski Brothers kept things tight and ludicrous, and not bloated “Speed Racer” to a mind-numbing 129 minutes with pointless subplots concerning stock takeovers and corporate fraud, I’d have an easier time defending it (that they gave bit parts to some of the original voice talent counts for a lot however). And even with the anemic performances (Fox and Allam being exceptions), protracted stretches of goofy dialogue, and the disturbing idea of a Japan largely free of Japanese people, there’s enough eye-popping goofiness to satisfy today’s Ritalin-dosed youth.

I’m no spring chicken, but the complaints about “Speed Racer’s” volume and seizure-inducing visuals sounds like the lamentations of a bunch of grandparents pining for the days of penny candy and segregated fountains. It’s the Wachowskis, people… what the fuck did you expect?

 
Jeff OConnell
READER
 
I think this film was made and released 15 years too late. Back in 1993, "Speed Racer" was experiencing a retro-revival craze in tandem with the American rave scene. There were "Speed Racer" techno sides with SP samples, and the series was being re-run on MTV almost non-stop. Like "Aeon Flux," the chasm of time between trend adaptation is too wide to make much of an impact (I predict).  
Posted on May 9, 2008, 12:30 pm
allenchampagne
READER
 
Exactly. I remember MTV used to show it before "Liquid Television." And the box office numbers confirm that. The second weekend of "Iron Man" is smoking it. And so is the Ashton/Cameron remake of Larry David's "Sour Grapes." I guess with this recession, people are saving up for Indiana Jones. Welp, I'm off to see "Redbelt."  
Posted on May 10, 2008, 11:14 am
FelixVasquez
STAFF WRITER
 
I kinda liked it.  
Posted on May 10, 2008, 3:00 pm
Isaac Borgo
READER
 
I don't know. I still don't think the Wachowskis have hit bottom. I think they've got even more over the top shitbombs in store for us.  
Posted on May 10, 2008, 4:47 pm
Mistermind
READER
 
I normally use Film Threat as my solo reference to movies before or even after watching, but I have to say I'm extremely disappointed by this review. I mean I'm no Speed's fan (and believe me I'll never will), but I know how to give credit to two directors who manage to pull an enjoyable and fun movie experience from a crappy cartoon from the 70's. Yes it is a crappy cartoon and everyone knows it, but like you said yourself, it was the beginning of the "anime" era (again, not an anime fan either). Sure it was childish. Sure it was seizure-inducing. But its still a great big screen experience. It seems in this review you're just forcing yourself not to like it simply cause you were influenced by external experiences before even watching it (like the fact that you apparently decided to hate the directors at some point in your life and it will stick to all your reviews). If you don't like this "genre" why review it? Maybe that is what happen to all reviewers eventually...  
Posted on May 12, 2008, 12:01 pm
Leave Comments:
UserName:
Password:
If you do not have a UserName or Password, register with Film Threat.
Comment:
Enter the text in the below image in the following space:
All HTML and other coding languages are stripped from the comments, so any added links or special text formating will not be active.
Read more reviews ...
  2009-11-19 - PROMETHEUS TRIUMPHANT: A FUGUE IN THE KEY OF FLESH  
  2009-11-19 - THE TWILIGHT SAGA: NEW MOON  
  2009-11-19 - TINTO BRASS' THE HOWL (L’URLO) (DVD)  
  2009-11-19 - BAD LIEUTENANT: PORT OF CALL NEW ORLEANS  
  2009-11-18 - POISON SWEETHEARTS  
  2009-11-17 - RIVER OF RENEWAL (DVD)  
  2009-11-17 - PLANET B-BOY (DVD)  
  2009-11-16 - 2012  
  2009-11-15 - INSIDE DARKNESS  
  2009-11-14 - GOOD EVENING FOLKS, WE’RE THE PINE BOX BOYS  
  2009-11-14 - ABBY  
  2009-11-13 - PIRATE RADIO  
  2009-11-13 - THE END OF POVERTY?  
  2009-11-12 - BONECRUSHER  
  2009-11-12 - NORTH BY NORTHWEST: 50TH ANNIVERSARY EDITION (DVD)  
  2009-11-11 - PAURA: LUCIO FULCI REMEMBERED VOL. 1 (DVD)  
  2009-11-11 - SUPER 8 GIRL GAMES (DVD)  
  2009-11-10 - UP: TWO-DISC DELUXE EDITION (DVD)  
  2009-11-10 - LOVE AND SAVAGERY  
  2009-11-08 - LUIS BUNUEL'S DEATH IN THE GARDEN (DVD)  
  2009-11-08 - PAROLES ET MUSIQUE (LOVE SONGS) (DVD)  
  2009-11-07 - THE MEN WHO STARE AT GOATS  
  2009-11-07 - CLONES GONE WILD  
  2009-11-06 - THE BOX  
  2009-11-06 - THE FOURTH KIND  
     

Headlines
 

Latest Blogs
TRUTH BEHIND "THE FOURTH KIND"? UNIVERSAL ASKS THAT YOU SEE FOR YOURSELF...
A FRIENDLY REMINDER -- FOLLOW FT ON TWITTER
"HOOTERS" WITH SCOOPERS
SOUND ON SIGHT: ANTICHRIST, FESTIVAL DU NOUVEAU CINEMA & A FEW OTHER THINGS
SOUND ON SIGHT: COPPOLA & THE COVE

NEW ON DVD!
UP: TWO-DISC DELUXE EDITION (DVD)
BALLAST
LUIS BUNUEL'S DEATH IN THE GARDEN (DVD)
FOOD, INC.
BATTLESTAR GALACTICA: THE PLAN (DVD)
UP
NORTH BY NORTHWEST: 50TH ANNIVERSARY EDITION (DVD)
STAR TREK

Film Threat Poll
Does 2012 deserve all the hype and coin it's getting?
1) Yes - it's bringing the world down!
2) It's a giant stink bomb.
3) Cusack and Harrelson should co-star in a gay romance.
In Theaters
BAD LIEUTENANT: PORT OF CALL NEW ORLEANS
THE TWILIGHT SAGA: NEW MOON
2012
PIRATE RADIO
THE MEN WHO STARE AT GOATS
THE FOURTH KIND
THE BOX
THIS IS IT
AN EDUCATION
SAW VI




Site Programming
Site Artwork
copyright © 1985-2009
Gore Group Publications
   
about | advertise | classifieds | legal | myspace | staff | submit for review | support