"I don't take checks, now slip me some cash and I'll slip you the wiener." - Adventures in Babysitting (1987) about | advertise | classifieds | legal | myspace | staff | submit for review | support
 
FREE Weekly Newsletter



 
 
     
 
   
  There’s not much humor had with any of the pulp references in the film...  
 
     
 
   
  I thought that Chan was upstaged in this film by Donnie Yen...  
 
     
SHANGHAI KNIGHTS
by David Grove
2003, Rated PG-13, 107 minutes, Touchstone Pictures
“Shanghai Knights” is a disappointment. This sequel to the highly enjoyable and stylish Shanghai Noon is a lazy and limp film, completely forgettable, that relies totally on the charm and physical grace of Jackie Chan to keep the whole thing from collapsing. He’s all by himself here and Jackie looks a little tired this time as if he still knows the moves, but not the feelings.

“Shanghai Knights” follows Chon Wang (Chan) as he reunites with his maverick and sly partner in crime Roy O’Bannon (Owen Wilson) after Chon learns that his estranged father has been murdered by a Chinese rebel. They track him down in London where, with the help of Chon’s sister, Chon and Roy discover a labyrinthine conspiracy to destroy the Royal Family by a sinister mastermind named Rathbone (Aidan Gillen) who has also stolen the Wang family’s Imperial Seal.

As in most of Chan’s fish-out-of-water action-comedies, Chan gets into deep trouble through cultural misunderstandings and Chan and Wilson soon get into a series of battles and chases with British Police and various villains, all the while bumping into such characters as Charlie Chaplin, Jack the Ripper and Sherlock Holmes. There’s not much humor had with any of the pulp references in the film, aside from some one-liners, unless you think it’s funny that the Londoners in this film all have yellow teeth. Wouldn’t you want to talk to Charlie Chaplin? Is Sherlock Holmes on the case of Jack the Ripper?

The first thing people want to know about a Jackie Chan film is how good the fight scenes are and, to be sure, the fight scenes in “Shanghai Knights” are as elaborately choreographed as anything Chan’s ever done, but they add up to less than we’ve seen in his other films, especially the wonderful The Legend of Drunken Master. For one thing, I thought that Chan was upstaged in this film by Donnie Yen, another Hong Kong fighting legend of Iron Monkey fame, who steals every scene he’s in with his fluid movements. Chan’s stunts in “Shanghai Knights” look kind of forced and stiff to me especially the “Singing in the Rain” parody that has gotten a lot of publicity. The scene starts out like a basic fight sequence and then Chan stumbles upon a table full of umbrellas, which he uses to fight with. It’s cute, but the scene doesn’t end like “Singing in the Rain,” it’s not nearly as physically impressive as Gene Kelly and I’m not sure I’d even know it was a “Singing in the Rain” tribute unless I was told beforehand. Chan even gets upstaged in the climactic sword battle between his character and Rathbone.

The story of “Shanghai Knights” is kind of a mess. I heard that “Shanghai Knights” was originally going to be just about the two guys going after Jack the Ripper in old England, but here it looks like they’ve thrown everything into the mix hoping that it would work. There’s also a lot of rough spots in the film too like in a scene where Rathbone holds a big fireworks show for the purpose of killing the Royal Family. When Chon’s sister, Lin, shows up to save the day, the members of Rathbone’s fireworks crew turn into Ninjas who are summarily killed off in such an illogical way that you’re not sure who did what to whom. Did Chan himself direct these scenes? I don’t know, but I’d be willing to bet that he directed the “Singing in the Rain” parody and the other big action setups and maybe that’s why everything looks so haphazard. The fireworks keep going and the crowd cheers even as one of the thugs falls out of a clock tower. It’s almost as if the sound disconnected or something. There’s also a lot of lowbrow sexual humor that feels like it doesn’t belong in a Jackie Chan movie. Chan’s character shows such little sense of awe at being in England in the early stages of the twentieth century that I wonder why they didn’t call this film “Chon and Roy’s Excellent Adventure.”

Maybe “Shanghai Knights,” along with Rush Hour 2 and “The Tuxedo,” is proof that Jackie Chan has fallen victim to the superstar syndrome that has recently infected the careers of Martin Lawrence and Eddie Murphy and which usually occurs when a star feels like he can do no wrong. Look what happened to other action stars like Bronson, Norris and Seagal who kicked their way to the top in stupid films that ultimately destroyed their box office credibility. Maybe the same thing will happen to Jackie.

Another problem with “Shanghai Knights” is Owen Wilson’s Roy O’Bannon character and how little of interest he’s given to do in this film. It’s like he’s sidelined in the film, a spectator to the endless fight setups and set pieces. At the start of the film, we learn that O’Bannon has become the hero of a popular series of western-adventure books, but there’s nothing done with the character except for the odd wisecrack. Wilson can be a lot of fun to watch and he was terrific in Shanghai Noon, but here, like the rest of the film, he’s kind of invisible. I would also like to state for a fact that fight scenes in absence of all other drama aren’t interesting to watch. Call me jaded, but don’t call me when they make “Shanghai Sunrise.”

 
 
   
  The story of “Shanghai Knights” is kind of a mess...  
Leave Comments:
UserName:
Password:
If you do not have a UserName or Password, register with Film Threat.
Comment:
Enter the text in the below image in the following space:
All HTML and other coding languages are stripped from the comments, so any added links or special text formating will not be active.
Read more reviews ...
  2009-11-19 - PROMETHEUS TRIUMPHANT: A FUGUE IN THE KEY OF FLESH  
  2009-11-19 - THE TWILIGHT SAGA: NEW MOON  
  2009-11-19 - TINTO BRASS' THE HOWL (L’URLO) (DVD)  
  2009-11-19 - BAD LIEUTENANT: PORT OF CALL NEW ORLEANS  
  2009-11-18 - POISON SWEETHEARTS  
  2009-11-17 - RIVER OF RENEWAL (DVD)  
  2009-11-17 - PLANET B-BOY (DVD)  
  2009-11-16 - 2012  
  2009-11-15 - INSIDE DARKNESS  
  2009-11-14 - GOOD EVENING FOLKS, WE’RE THE PINE BOX BOYS  
  2009-11-14 - ABBY  
  2009-11-13 - PIRATE RADIO  
  2009-11-13 - THE END OF POVERTY?  
  2009-11-12 - BONECRUSHER  
  2009-11-12 - NORTH BY NORTHWEST: 50TH ANNIVERSARY EDITION (DVD)  
  2009-11-11 - PAURA: LUCIO FULCI REMEMBERED VOL. 1 (DVD)  
  2009-11-11 - SUPER 8 GIRL GAMES (DVD)  
  2009-11-10 - UP: TWO-DISC DELUXE EDITION (DVD)  
  2009-11-10 - LOVE AND SAVAGERY  
  2009-11-08 - LUIS BUNUEL'S DEATH IN THE GARDEN (DVD)  
  2009-11-08 - PAROLES ET MUSIQUE (LOVE SONGS) (DVD)  
  2009-11-07 - THE MEN WHO STARE AT GOATS  
  2009-11-07 - CLONES GONE WILD  
  2009-11-06 - THE BOX  
  2009-11-06 - THE FOURTH KIND  
     

Headlines
 

Latest Blogs
TRUTH BEHIND "THE FOURTH KIND"? UNIVERSAL ASKS THAT YOU SEE FOR YOURSELF...
A FRIENDLY REMINDER -- FOLLOW FT ON TWITTER
"HOOTERS" WITH SCOOPERS
SOUND ON SIGHT: ANTICHRIST, FESTIVAL DU NOUVEAU CINEMA & A FEW OTHER THINGS
SOUND ON SIGHT: COPPOLA & THE COVE

NEW ON DVD!
UP: TWO-DISC DELUXE EDITION (DVD)
BALLAST
LUIS BUNUEL'S DEATH IN THE GARDEN (DVD)
FOOD, INC.
BATTLESTAR GALACTICA: THE PLAN (DVD)
UP
NORTH BY NORTHWEST: 50TH ANNIVERSARY EDITION (DVD)
STAR TREK

Film Threat Poll
Does 2012 deserve all the hype and coin it's getting?
1) Yes - it's bringing the world down!
2) It's a giant stink bomb.
3) Cusack and Harrelson should co-star in a gay romance.
In Theaters
BAD LIEUTENANT: PORT OF CALL NEW ORLEANS
THE TWILIGHT SAGA: NEW MOON
2012
PIRATE RADIO
THE MEN WHO STARE AT GOATS
THE FOURTH KIND
THE BOX
THIS IS IT
AN EDUCATION
SAW VI




Site Programming
Site Artwork
copyright © 1985-2009
Gore Group Publications
   
about | advertise | classifieds | legal | myspace | staff | submit for review | support