ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST

2.5 Stars
Year Released: 1968
MPAA Rating: Unrated
Running Time: 127 minutes
Click to Expand Credits:

I was never a fan of Sergio Leone, but my prejudice is easy to trace. I came to his films during the days of pre-cable television, when his Westerns were shown on TV in edited, pan-and-scan versions interrupted every 15 minutes by commercials. This is not the way to see a Leone movie.

Fortunately, his 1968 epic “Once Upon a Time in the West” is getting a theatrical re-release in a new 35mm Scope print (screen ratio 2:35:1) and in the original uncut version (the first American release was missing 20 minutes). Indeed, this is the only way to appreciate Leone’s style: as he intended it to be seen, on a very big screen.

The film is rich in style, with its intense close-ups, sweeping panoramas of the Old West (Utah and Arizona landscapes mixed with Spanish and Italian scenery – it is hard to tell Old West from Old Europe), the brilliant use of Ennio Morricone’s inventive score (recorded before the film was shot, with Leone pacing his action to the music), and the extraordinary sound editing and engineering. The classic opening title sequence, with the bandits waiting for the late train, is a masterpiece of sound recording – from the squeak of the battered windmill atop the station to the buzz of a pesky fly to the flutter of a ticket blowing across the station, it is an aural work of art.

The film is also rightly celebrated for its daring casting of Henry Fonda as the steely-eyed assassin and Charles Bronson as the mysterious hero. Prior to this film, Fonda was the reigning movie good guy while Bronson was typically typecast as a heavy. This remarkable switch in personas helped to jumpstart Bronson into heroic starring roles while it gave Fonda one of his greatest performances on film. Reliable character actors Jack Elam, Woody Strode, Lionel Stander and Keenan Wynn also turn up for memorable guest appearances.

Alas, the big screen also magnifies the problems with “Once Upon a Time in the West.” Specifically, Leone’s insistence on style trumped the need for substance. The film is basically a B-Western stretched an agonizing 165 minutes, and its tale of a farmer’s widow trying to fight off attempts by a railroad baron to steal her land could’ve easily been told in half that time. The film took advantage of looser studio controls of 1968 to include a couple of barnyard expletives and to identify the farmer’s widow as an ex-whore from New Orleans (and, yes, they say “whore”).

Also, the brilliant casting of Fonda and Bronson was diluted by the inadequate performance of Jason Robards as the comic bandito who gets to play good guy against the railroad meanies (he is never truly funny or compelling in this part) and the disastrous miscasting of Claudia Cardinale as the ex-whore/farmer’s widow/center of attention. With her flowing wig, deep cleavage and false eyelashes, she looks like she belongs in Cinecitta of the 1960s rather than Carson City of the 1860s. And while there is no denying Cardinale was gorgeous, the sad truth is that she was a terrible actress (which may explain why she never rivaled Lollobrigida or Loren as a major Italian export).

Leone’s films have their cult, so there is no sense in trying to dissuade them that this flick is flawed. But for those who never saw the film or only know it from the small screen, it deserves to be seen in a theater and this is a rare chance to take it in correctly.



Posted on September 29, 2005 in Reviews by
Buffer


If you liked this article then you may also like the following Film Threat articles:
Popular Stories from Around the Web
4 Comments on "ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST"

  1. FilmDog on Fri, 23rd Apr 2010 4:04 am 

    This is a horrible half-inaccurate review by someone quite ignorant and biased (he admits it at the start). For one, there was basically no Italian “scenery” as suggested. It insults one of the greatest films of all-time. For example, imdb.com polls it at #23 which is very high considering half the films rated are new films. Suggesting it is a B-western stretched an agonizing 165 minutes is a wild claim. If so, what is a B-western??! Are all westerns B? What’s a A-western? The script, for example, is clearly no B-western but a philosophical statement of death and changing myth of the western gunslinger. Unlike the author claims, there are NO “barnyard expletives”…maybe he says them on the toilet where he belongs. It’s an opera with the depth of a Shakespearian play and a tribute to about 50 westerns (do the research). Jason Robards was cast fine although perhaps not as brilliantly as Fonda but he holds his role as well as Bronson. Claudia Cardinale was never an true export unlike the author claims because she chose to do most of her movies in Europe. In fact, her movies are more celebrated in arthouses (a local art museum showed 3 of her films recently) than Gina or Sophia. Apparently the author has hardly seen any of her earlier Italian films where she excels. Hollywood however often doesn’t require acting but merely showcases a name. The movie is slow-paced but so are many other great films that develop drama and a plot. For example, watch Lawrence of Arabia…the desert scenes are long and slow. That does not detract from the movie. In fact, many of the worst B-movies from the typical 50s were under 90 minutes…or look at the Lord of the Ring series or Star Wars…(long movies)…tell me pace and quality are related. Sorry, NOT!


    Report Comment

  2. Scott on Tue, 27th Jul 2010 1:45 pm 

    Although the cinematography is excellent and the landscapes and the stars are gorgeous, this movie is ridiculous! The dialogue is insipid through-out. The only way to enjoy the film is as a parody of Westerns. Aside from the principal characters, I couldn’t keep straight the bad guys from the good guys. A great deal of gratuitous violence and cruelty, to no good purpose!


    Report Comment

  3. Einest on Mon, 17th Jan 2011 7:48 am 

    Haha, one of the worst reviews I have ever read, and concidering that this is internet where everyone is raising their opinions aloud, it says a lot about the author of this carbage.


    Report Comment

  4. Peter on Thu, 31st Mar 2011 7:12 pm 

    LOL!
    Totally ridiculous review!

    Once upon a time in the West is worldfamous for it’s soundtrack, actors and story.
    It is considered a masterpiece and probably one of the best westerns ever made.

    The person who wrote this review is totally biased (and deaf and blind) for sure.


    Report Comment

Tell us what you're thinking...





Comments are governed by the Terms of Use of this Site. Click on the "Report Comment" link if you feel a comment is in violation of the Terms of Use, and the comment will be reviewed appropriately.